Syllabus for FYSM 100

Ethics of Hunting and Fishing

Fall 2008


Tim Wahls
office: Tome 244
office hours: TF 1:30 - 2:45 p.m, W 2:45 - 3:45 p.m., R 11:00 a.m. - 12:00 p.m. and by appointment
phone: (717) 245 - 1743
email: wahlst@dickinson.edu
course URL: http://users.dickinson.edu/~wahlst/fysm/

Library Liason: Amelia Brunskill
Writing Center Liason: Zak Rosenberg
Learning Community Coordinators: Kerstin Martin and Brendan Gallagher

Required Texts

A Sand County Almanac (with Essays on Conservation from Round River). Aldo Leopold. Ballantine Books, 1970. ISBN: 3-345-34505-3

American Sportsmen and the Origins of Conservation, 3rd edition. John F. Reiger.Oregon State University Press, 2000. ISBN: 0-87071-487-2

A Writer's Reference, sixth edition. Diana Hacker. Bedford/St. Martin's, 2007. ISBN: 0-312-45025-7

Course Description

Animal populations around the world face increasing pressure from habitat destruction and other environmental impacts of human population growth and economic development. Ironically, these same animal populations support hunting and fishing activities that provide recreation for millions of people and generate billions of dollars in revenue every year. In this seminar, we will examine issues such as the role of hunting in managing animal populations, the ethics of hunting and fishing for "wild" animals that have been raised in captivity, the environmental impacts of hatcheries and stocked fish, whether hunting and fishing cause animals to experience pain and fear, and the morality of catch-and-release fishing.

Course Goals

Environmental Change and Human Decisions Cluster

This seminar is part of the Environmental Change and Human Decisions cluster. All students in our seminar are also taking ECON 111 (Microeconomics) with Professor Tynan and ENST 131 (Introduction to Environmental Science) with Professor Wilderman. Additionally, our seminar is linked with Professor Vetter's seminar (Sustaining Places: National Parks, Forests, Farms, and Communities) in a learning community. All of these courses are linked - you will find the same topics being discussed (from different perspectives) in each of these courses, and many out-of-class activities and field trips will be related to two or more of your courses. You will be living in the same residence hall with the students from Professsor Vetter's seminar, as well as students from two other seminars with sustainability themes.

The cluster is supported by two "Learning Community Coordinators" who live with you. The Learning Community Coordinator (LCC) is an upper-level student who has several roles. The LCC handles the many logistical details of LC events. While the LCC is not taking your seminar, he or she has read some of the key texts assigned in the seminar. You may find it interesting to seek out your LCC to speak about the ideas and issues you are encountering. Most importantly, your LCC will be looking for ways to encourage deeper student engagement with the themes of our cluster. Your Learning Community Coordinators are Kerstin Martin and Brendan Gallagher.

Our cluster has a web site which can be accessed from http://www.dickinson.edu/departments/learncomm. When you select the Cluster from the list, you will find that the LCCs have set up a calendar for programs and events that might interest you.

Assignments and Evaluation

Assignments for the semester and the weights for each are given in the following table:

Assignment Weight
Class Participation 20%
Argumentative Paper #1 10%
Argumentative Paper #2 15%
Peer Review 5%
Library Assignments 5%
Visits to Writing Center 5%
Final Project Annotated Bibliography 5%
Final Project First Draft 10%
Final Project Second Draft 15%
Final Project Presentation 10%

Attendance and Class Participation

As this class is discussion and presentation-based, attendance is critical. Each student is allowed one unexcused absence per semester. For each additional unexcused absence, 3% will be deducted from your course grade for the semester. Note that we will be having class on Monday, November 24.

I will assign a class participation grade to each student immediately following each class that has a significant discussion component. Emphasis will be placed on the quality of your contributions to the discussion, not the quantity. The ideas and opinions that you present should be original, logical and grounded in fact. Dominating the discussion or refusing to listen to others is strongly discouraged. You will be expected to contribute one discussion question for each discussion class, and your participation grade will be based in part on the quality of this question. Your question should be designed to encourage discussion. In particular, questions with a yes-no answer and factual questions from the reading are not acceptable.

Each student will also be required to help with one stream improvement project. These projects are scheduled for four Saturdays: September 20 and 27, and October 4 and 18. See the course schedule for more details. You are encouraged to help with more than one project, and in fact helping with additional projects will count toward requirements for your environmental science class. Failure to participate in at least one stream improvement project will result in a 3% deduction from your course grade for the semester.

Late Assignments

Assignments will be due at the beginning of class on the due date. Late assignments will not be accepted for credit unless arrangements are made with me in advance or in case of emergencies. Emergencies include sudden illness or injury (student or family member), or events such as automobile breakdowns, that prevent the student from completing an assignment or attending class to turn in an assignment. Events under the control of the student, such as oversleeping or appointments of any kind, do not constitute emergencies. In cases that seem questionable, I will require proof that an emergency occurred.

Academic Dishonesty

Students are expected to uphold the Community Standards and Procedures for Academic Conduct (beginning on page 7 of the pamphlet Dickinson College Community Standards). Specifically, the following forms of academic dishonesty are violations of those standards: plagiarism, allowing another student to copy your work or your ideas, submitting work previously used in another class without informing the instructor, and tampering with the work of others. Plagiarism is defined as follows by the Dickinson College Community Standards:
  1. To plagiarize is to use without proper citation or acknowledgment, the words, ideas or work of another. Whenever one relies on someone else for phraseology, even for only two or three words, one must acknowledge indebtedness by using quotation marks and giving the source, either in the text or in a footnote.
  2. When one borrows facts which are not matters of general knowledge, including all statistics and translations, one must indicate ones indebtedness in the text or footnote. When one borrows an idea or logic of an argument, one must acknowledge indebtedness either in a footnote or in the text. When in doubt - footnote.
Incidents of suspected academic dishonesty will be handled through the Disciplinary System of the College, as described in the Student Code of Conduct and Disciplinary System.

Accommodations for Disabilities

In compliance with the Dickinson College policy and equal access laws, I am available to discuss appropriate academic accommodations that may be recommended for students with disabilities. Requests for academic accommodations are to be made during the first three weeks of the semester (except for unusual circumstances) so that timely and appropriate arrangements can be made.

Students are required to register with Academic Resource Services in the Advising Office located on the first floor of Biddle House (contact ext. 1080 or waybranj@dickinson.edu) to verify their eligibility for appropriate accommodations.

Tentative Course Schedule

Date Topic
Aug 22 Introduction and Advising
Aug 25 Ethical Frameworks
Aug 26 Academic Integrity Session
6:00 p.m., Information Commons Classroom of the Library
Aug 27 Welcome Dinner (Neil Leary)
6:00 p.m., Stafford Lecture Room, Rector Science Complex
Aug 28 Animal Rights
Sep 1 Hunting as Pest/Predator Control (visit to the farm)
presented by: Matt Steinman and Jenn Halpin, Department of Environmental Studies
Sep 4 Finding Books and Journal Articles (Library Visit)
Sep 8 The Alliance for Aquatic Resource Monitoring (ALLARM)
Sep 11 Writing Thesis Statements
Viewing of "Our Local Treasure: The Letort Spring Run"
Sep 15 The Sportsperson's Code
Sep 18 Peer Review (Paper #1 first draft due)
Sep 20 Letort Habitat Improvement (Work Day) (Pictures)
Sep 22 Visit to the Huntsdale Fish Hatchery
Sep 25 Fish Hatcheries and Fish Stocking
Sep 27 Letort Cleanup (Work Day) (Pictures)
Sep 29 Angling and the Environment
presented by: Fred Bohls, Cumberland Valley Trout Unlimited
Oct 2 Using Databases and Evaluating Websites (Library Visit)
Oct 4 Conodoguinet Creek Cleanup at Willow Mill Park (Work Day) (Pictures)
Oct 6 Catch and Release Fishing
Oct 9 viewing of "A River Runs Through It"
Oct 13 Fall Pause
Oct 16 Peer Review (Paper #2 first draft due)
Oct 18 Big Spring Cleanup (Work Day) (Pictures)
Oct 20 Meeting with Whitey Ellerman
Oct 23 Choosing a Topic for a Research Paper (Library Session)
Oct 27 Stream Access (Private Rights and the Public Good)
Oct 30 Hunting as Wildlife Management
Nov 3 Origins of the National Park System
Nov 6 Commercial Fishing and the Tragedy of the Commons
Nov 10 Hunting, Fishing and Families
Nov 13 Common Hour
Working Sustainably with Communities
presented by: ALLARM
noon, Weiss Center, Rubendall Recital Hall

Regular class meeting canceled.

The Pflaum Lecture
Sustainable Suburbia? Making Connections among Land, History, Education, and Community
presented by: Dr. Brian Donahue, Brandeis University
7:00 p.m., Stern Center Great Room

Nov 17 The Evolution of an Angler
presented by: Denny Moore
Nov 20 The Land Ethic
Nov 24 Final Presentations
Nov 27 Thanksgiving Break
Dec 1 Final Presentations
Dec 4 Final Presentations
Dec 5 Final Papers Due at 12:00 p.m. (noon)